Blog Tools
Edit your Blog
Build a Blog
View Profile
17 Aug, 09 > 23 Aug, 09
29 Dec, 08 > 4 Jan, 09
22 Dec, 08 > 28 Dec, 08
8 Sep, 08 > 14 Sep, 08
4 Aug, 08 > 10 Aug, 08
30 Jun, 08 > 6 Jul, 08
2 Jun, 08 > 8 Jun, 08
24 Dec, 07 > 30 Dec, 07
23 Jul, 07 > 29 Jul, 07
26 Mar, 07 > 1 Apr, 07
19 Mar, 07 > 25 Mar, 07
26 Feb, 07 > 4 Mar, 07
23 Oct, 06 > 29 Oct, 06
3 Jul, 06 > 9 Jul, 06
20 Feb, 06 > 26 Feb, 06
6 Feb, 06 > 12 Feb, 06
17 Oct, 05 > 23 Oct, 05
10 Oct, 05 > 16 Oct, 05
15 Aug, 05 > 21 Aug, 05
8 Aug, 05 > 14 Aug, 05
30 May, 05 > 5 Jun, 05
23 May, 05 > 29 May, 05
28 Mar, 05 > 3 Apr, 05
24 Jan, 05 > 30 Jan, 05
17 Jan, 05 > 23 Jan, 05
8 Nov, 04 > 14 Nov, 04
13 Sep, 04 > 19 Sep, 04
23 Aug, 04 > 29 Aug, 04
16 Aug, 04 > 22 Aug, 04
26 Jan, 04 > 1 Feb, 04
22 Dec, 03 > 28 Dec, 03
8 Dec, 03 > 14 Dec, 03
3 Nov, 03 > 9 Nov, 03
27 Oct, 03 > 2 Nov, 03
13 Oct, 03 > 19 Oct, 03
You are not logged in. Log in
Entries by Topic
All topics  «
Meditations on Teaching, Learning, and Understanding
Saturday, 13 September 2008
It just breaks my heart

Each September I give my students a general survey to fill out, and two of the questions I ask them are about what subjects did they like most and least the previous year and describe why.

Responses vary. Being middle school students, it's never any surprise that they enjoy the Explorations subjects (music, physical education, art, etc), and my new students are no exception. But this year what is a surprise is how many students wrote down math as their least liked subject.

There are always a few students each year who indicate that they didn't enjoy math, but this year almost half the students in both of my core classes wrote it down. Half! Reasons included:

- I didn't really get it

- It was hard

- I didn't get a very good grade

- I'm not good at it

This past week I've been doing some exploration type activities, to see what kinds of patterns they find, what sort of things they notice, circulating and chatting with them as they work, having class discussions where they can volunteer to go up to the whiteboard or the overhead projector and explain their ideas. As the week went on, there were more and more volunteers.

And the thing is, they are good at it, they do get it.

This dichotomy between their perception of their abilities and the reality of what they can do just breaks my heart.

Every year I start off with the goal of having math classes where all students realise that math is theirs, that it's interesting and enjoyable. Every year I get worn down at some point (by external factors that perhaps I'll describe at another time) and find myself being more, uh, let's say "traditional" in my approach. Sometimes I rebound, sometimes I don't.

May this be the year that I make it all the way til the end of June.

 

 


Posted by msarmstrong at 12:32 PM PDT
Updated: Saturday, 13 September 2008 12:33 PM PDT
Post Comment | View Comments (1) | Permalink

Friday, 28 November 2008 - 1:25 PM PST

Name: "Peter Cook"
Home Page: http://www.chezplj.ca

Sounds like this is the root: 

http://www.activityvillage.co.uk/never_tell_your_kids_theyre_smart.htm

 To quote:

Dweck's team studied the effects of a series of experiments on 400 New York City fifth-graders in which the children were either praised based on their intelligence or on their effort after completing nonverbal puzzles. In the end, it was the kids who believed they worked hard, versus those who simply thought their scores were the result of innate intelligence, that scored significantly higher on later tests. They also expended considerably more effort on the puzzles Dweck's team administered. In fact, many in the "You must have worked really hard" group said they actually enjoyed the most difficult tests - tests they were never expected to do well in - while many in the "You must be smart at this" group simply gave up.

"Emphasizing effort gives [children] a variable they can control. They come to see themselves as in control of their success. Emphasizing natural intelligence takes it out of the child's control, and it provides no good recipe for responding to failure," Dweck explained. This proved true for every socioeconomic class, both genders (though the most intelligent girls were the most dramatically effected), and very young children.

 Also see: 

http://www.sciam.com/article.cfm?id=the-secret-to-raising-smart-kids&print=true

View Latest Entries